Mine are the same as what you are thinking. I currently have a set of husky exact contours and a set of weathertech HP’s for the truck, and my daughter has the regular weathertechs for her car.
The husky exact contours are a soft, heavy, pliable rubber. You could fold them in half, and park a car on them in sub zero temps, and they will go right back to shape and lay down the way they are supposed to.
The HP’s are weathertech’s attempt at making a mat like the exact contours, but failed, as they are still more rigid and plastic like.
The regular weathertechs are straight up plastic junk. My work boots slip all over the place on them, and they curl up around the edges in the cold.