gimmie11s
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Mar 30, 2021
- Messages
- 2,401
- Reaction score
- 3,567
I’m not sure what was unfair…just commenting on my experience. Pros and cons as I said. I also wasn’t trying to compare the two as I’m well aware that diesel and gas systems are two very different animals. I was more using my experience with one vs the other as a point of reference - sorry I wasn’t clearer on that.
I debated over ordering the Cummins - its reputation is bulletproof and I’m sure it would handle my 7000# trailer with ease. Given the relatively light towing load, the amount of non-towing driving we do with the truck, and overall additional lifelong expense of a diesel system, I opted for gas. A mechanic friend and I were discussing this and his view is that the gas engine is designed to do exactly what it’s doing and it’s nothing to worry about. Of course - now I’m anticipating 5000+RPM on anything above a 9% grade and let’s just say that’s going to feel unsettling even if that’s exactly what it’s designed and built to do….
The Chevy only got 13.5 mpg towing anyway so it’s not like either “animal” gets high marks on fuel efficiency. If CSX trains can move one ton of weight 492 miles on one gallon of fuel, then truck manufacturers should be working on similar hybrids that can move a 7.5 ton rig 65.6 miles on one gallon of fuel. At that rate, a tiny 10 gallon tank would provide 656 miles of range. That wouldn’t suck!
I think the practical reality of tank RANGE being so limited is worth noting. A suggestion has been made that I might be able to swap in the 50 gallon tank and I will absolutely look in to that to address that concern. Even if I can only get 8 mpg towing at true highway speeds, at least that buys me more reasonable overall range.
First world problems no matter how you slice it for sure - just putting it out there.
You made the best decision you possibly could given the primary use/s of your new truck.
Just understand where you "compromised" in your decision is towing. Accept that the gas motor will be working harder during this type of use and it is what it is. You won't hurt it, although those steep grades will have you staring at your gauges im sure.
The upside is a beautiful sounding motor, a quicker, more "light" feeling truck when unloaded, and an up front savings of $9k+.