What's new
Ram Heavy Duty Forum

Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Grid Heater Banks Monster Ram P0111/P0299

I just laugh, laugh and laugh again when all the bank$ fanboy$ talk about how the bank$ intake, intercooler pipe$, and intake horn flow 1008 cfm WHEN THE STOCK HEAD CAN ONLY FLOW 165! Reminds me of when someone passes me on a double yellow line just to catch the next red traffic light. A very wise man once said “A fool and his money are soon parted”….

the banks fan boy makes me think he has 4 inch wheel spaces with custom offset stickers on his back window and rubber band tires on 24's and then tells people it rides like its on a cloud with stick on monster energy tats.

I had all the banks stuff. and i can for a fact tell you that as nice and as expensive as it is its still the same truck. you would think a 40 year old diesel pro would know better. prob the same tech working on dinkys truck at the last dealership.

im more amused at the offroad comment. he's bragging to the wrong guy lol.

IMG_1430.jpg
 
the banks fan boy makes me think he has 4 inch wheel spaces with custom offset stickers on his back window and rubber band tires on 24's and then tells people it rides like its on a cloud with stick on monster energy tats.

I had all the banks stuff. and i can for a fact tell you that as nice and as expensive as it is its still the same truck. you would think a 40 year old diesel pro would know better. prob the same tech working on dinkys truck at the last dealership.

im more amused at the offroad comment. he's bragging to the wrong guy lol.

View attachment 77849

Oh boy, looks like you've had mud half way up your tires there. Careful now.
 
"LOL. I think you moved a decimal". Yeah . . . nope . . . it wasn't 800%. It was more like 88.3% in my truck. I can't account for another generation's air horn (like the video suggests). I don't doubt that test you posted either; I just don't think Banks cares about a product they stopped supporting when Bush was still in office. I love it when haters use irrelevant info to make an argument. In actuality, in that video, both the Banks and the stock intake look similar. The one I installed . . . not so much.

A site for non-haters for educational purposes.


Coupled with the fact that air had to flow through those soot covered fins the engine was choked. The outflow (at the flange) area of the replacement is almost three times the area. I know that Banks did some testing on the air horn. It is their data. That data can be skewed to benefit them. Yeah, yeah, yeah, I get it. The next best competitor cost $600. I got my Banks system at the military discount of 10% off the list price of about $900 (price at the time). So, I dropped a little more than $800. But this included the replacement plate (pictured below) and new heater element. The new element looks like a very heavy spring (pictured below, it is about 1/4 diameter spring steel) that screws into the port shown in the flange opening of the air horn above (the plug). So, $200 for that plate and the new heater, was chump change to me. This made the cost a wash. Exceptional machining and manufacturing on all parts. The finish was perfect, both their powdercoating and anodizing. Interesting though, ALL of the other intakes on the market reuse the stock heater plate. For me, that fixes nothing. Remember that Banks info is compelling enough to win a multi-million-dollar contract from the government. This is fact. Maybe that had a little to do with me being pro-Banks. I don't know.

For the record, two things: 1) FANBOY - I take that as a compliment, and I appreciate it. You can make it my nickname; I don't give a crap. Nothing you say, joke, ridicule, poke, jab, or offend will change that. I am only telling you what I know. I drive the truck at least 70 miles per day. I smile thinking about the haters that know very little but profess to be intellects in matters where they are obvious simpletons. I admit that I am a novice. I can spit info on what I have installed which is based on what I have read and researched on everything that I could get info on. I am not sitting on a pinnacle shouting this is the best thing, only that it is what I chose to put on my truck and that it exceeded my expectations. If you chose a different route, tell me what it is and how it is treating you. With what I have done? Take it or leave it. 2) I have already established that I didn't do this for POWER, which is all anyone that have responded with hate can reference. I did it because of that grid bolt worry. Period. This is the only system that has an answer. A Siemens nuclear millwright that I used to work with experienced the bolt breaking off, falling down the intake, rolling to the back of the intake, landing in cylinder 6, and taking out his engine . . . in the middle of nowhere . . . towing his 5th wheel. A colossal goatfuk. Not only was it a nightmare to get help, but no warranty meant it cost him. I don't know, can someone tell me the cost of a 6.7 Cummins? My truck at the time was newer, but I took no time in getting that heater plate out of my engine bay. I just rely on my truck too much to have this happen. Hope for the best, plan for the worst. So, the real reason for my expenditures (stated a second time for slow learners) renders everyone's point moot.

Flow, power, mud, your amusement, blah, blah, blah, I didn't hear a word you said. Can't hurt my feelings, I don't have any. Marriage will do that to you. Like I stated in an earlier post, the added power (meaning seat of pants acceleration, push you back into your seat, throttle response, faster spool up, etc.) was a bonus. Numbers above prove, (with info, not conjecture) that it flows better. The math works. I'll admit, it is marketing info to sell a product. But here is the kicker . . . not one competitor has refuted it. Not. One. The silence is loud as fuk. Hate all you want. Hell, I only posted when someone experienced the exact same problem I had. I went through an ordeal to arrive at a simple fix. Then it happened to a second person, and voila!! We got his problem fixed and it took only him a few minutes!! I only hope I helped the first guy who asked for insight. This is the reason why I go to these sites. More to get help, but to offer it when I have it. For instance, the installation of the puck system. I have a simple way. I morphed it from someone else's method, but I made it simple. Without posts of substance, I would be left up to instructions that was seemingly written by a drunk Chinese adolescent.

Let's see . . . what other BS that was spewed . . . Oh yeah, head flow numbers . . . you have to remember to multiply the flow rate by the number of cylinders the engine has to. The number offered was 150 cfm per cylinder. I appreciate it when those who are trying to ridicule me actually make my point. The flow numbers for a stock head are between 150-170 cfm/cylinder. So, the head flows about 900 cfm or better. I am not sure where the 1008 cfm flow number came from, but Banks actually flows at 936 cfm. This puts the flow for the air horn and the head in concert. I added the boost tubes because they are a little shorter, bigger in diameter (less parasitic drag). They effectively took out elbows which is death to fluid dynamics. Does it matter? By itself, probably not, but as a system, eh maybe. Just so you know, the AFE offering for boost tubes cost more . . . just in case you want to hate on that too. Since Banks isn't the only player making aftermarket tubes, there must be something to it . . . don't ya think? Hell, what do I know, you are the authority . . . right?

So, other spewed, and worthless crap for amusement . . . stock looking truck, no stickers, stock size tires, rides like a whore on meth . . . unless I am pulling a trailer. If you had all the banks stuff on this generation truck, and you didn't feel any change . . . I'll take you for a ride in mine. Everyone, and I mean everyone, unsolicited, asks what I have done to it. That may mean something to anyone other than haters. Let's see . . . I don't go off-roading; I never seek the mud or those conditions. I don't see playing in the mud as fun. It doesn't make me money. I have friends that do, more power to them. I prefer clean. I was only making a point about the open part of my cold air intake. You blew it out of proportion and took it out of context. Childish, probably, but I got a laugh out of it too since you are trying to change the dialog. You see, I don't care how you see things or take things. Offer information that I can use . . . something of substance. Be abusive, I don't give a crap about that either; that is noise, I don't hear it. What you have to offer, I'll take it under advisement, maybe I'll use it. Or don't, I still don't give a crap. I'll still offer my help where I know something or can offer my experiences to those that can use it. I am not a liar, nor will I mislead. My truck is a tool that I use for work . . . sometimes the campgrounds have unimproved roads where some of those mud puddles were deep, maybe not deep for you, but I am towing a 36' camper. Mud halfway up the tires in that situation is deep for me. It has happened more times than I care to brag about. Not necessarily mud all the time, but gravel, dust, dirt, and all versions of water that you will find on industrial construction sites in various depths and consistencies. And to my point, my intake was dry, is dry, stays dry . . . gets dusty type of dirty but that is why you can clean it and move on. But let's not fool ourselves by comparing your mudder beast to how I use my truck. Again, apples to apples.

I rather enjoy this banter.

g
 

Attachments

  • Monster compare to stock.jpg
    Monster compare to stock.jpg
    60 KB · Views: 9
  • Banks heater plate.jpg
    Banks heater plate.jpg
    62.3 KB · Views: 11
  • Banks Flow Numbers 1.jpg
    Banks Flow Numbers 1.jpg
    53.3 KB · Views: 11
  • Banks heater.jpg
    Banks heater.jpg
    46.4 KB · Views: 11
didn't read. wall of words = you not caring, i guess.

let's just go ahead and agree your truck is amazing and carry on. no one here other than other 1 post members will care about banks.
 
didn't read. wall of words = you not caring, i guess.

let's just go ahead and agree your truck is amazing and carry on. no one here other than other 1 post members will care about banks.
. . . opinions vary . . . if I can help the one post member then it is what this site is for . . . right? I am guessing it isn't for hateful banter.
 
. . . opinions vary . . .

yes you are right. yours and ours.

We pretty much know you know very little about anything so at this point your just preaching to the choir. You saw gale banks on youtubes and just fell into the trap of good marketing and now you are yelling to the world how great you are for being stupid.

Everyone here (for the most part) are a wealth of knowledge. we know these trucks in and out. And well, you will be hard pressed to find anyone that thinks what your are saying is true, let alone worth doing.

Either way, great job.

Banks CAI - Provides nothing over stock other then sound, and less filtration.
Monster intake - Flows a ton of air until it gets to the head. no gain. no improvement. Yes no bolt anymore, but that bolt failing is rare. so rare in fact, its almost a myth.
intercooler tubes - lol

you actually lose power at this point. if you gained power you know gale would charge double.
 
It was more like 88.3% in my truck.

You're literally quoting the marketing material.

This is the only system that has an answer.

BD diesel makes a $200 solution that keeps the stock grid heater.



Doesn't care: posts wall of text. LOL

At this point, it seems like we're just arguing with someone that's a bit on the spectrum and trying to justify their spend, so I'm done.

To the casual reader, if this presents a solution for you, go for it. Just remember Gale Banks would sell ice to an Eskimo if he thought he could make a buck. There's a reason there are nothing but 5-star reviews on their products everywhere (lawyers and editors) and no negative youtube videos (lawyers).

Do your research on the forums where the old timers hang out. You'll find that all these expensive parts do not provide any performance benefit unless you tune your truck for 500+ HP.

You also have potential for a dealer to flag your truck for warranty denial. You can argue Magnuson-Moss all you want but good luck fighting it while you're trying to get something covered.
 
You're literally quoting the marketing material.



BD diesel makes a $200 solution that keeps the stock grid heater.



Doesn't care: posts wall of text. LOL

At this point, it seems like we're just arguing with someone that's a bit on the spectrum and trying to justify their spend, so I'm done.

To the casual reader, if this presents a solution for you, go for it. Just remember Gale Banks would sell ice to an Eskimo if he thought he could make a buck. There's a reason there are nothing but 5-star reviews on their products everywhere (lawyers and editors) and no negative youtube videos (lawyers).

Do your research on the forums where the old timers hang out. You'll find that all these expensive parts do not provide any performance benefit unless you tune your truck for 500+ HP.

You also have potential for a dealer to flag your truck for warranty denial. You can argue Magnuson-Moss all you want but good luck fighting it while you're trying to get something covered.

Well said dad. This is why we have adults around
 
Craig,

I have Banks everything on my 3/4-ton 2020 Ram Limited. I have the cold air, boost tubes, monster ram, 5" exhaust, pedal monster and two supergauges in the dual pod. Truely amazing engineering and awesome gear!!

So, the spring clamp on the bottom of your throttle body needs to be tighter than you probably have it. It will be the only place that you breeched the system to install the monster ram. If that is tight, the rest will be OK. So, I don't think you have an air leak, that rush of air is the increased air out of the intercooler through the Monster Ram and through the new heater plate. You got more air flow; get used to it. It took me and finally my wife to realize that it is the new normal.

Anyway, the exact same thing happening to you, happened to me. Same codes. Exact same thing with fuel economy. Excessive regen's. One of the codes is parasitic (one caused the other; fix one, the other goes away). I had the truck at Ram on three separate occasions, each time they claimed the problem solved. Each time after a few days, the codes came back. In total, they had the truck for almost two months. They gave it back to me without fixing it, stating the modifications I made were incompatible with the computer and that it needed to go back to stock. During this process, I spoke to many Banks technical support guys. The last one didn't go down the same rabbit holes as the others I had spoken to. He suggested I check the plugs on my EGR temp sensor and the heater plate temp sensor (the one repositioned in the new heater plate that has the new pigtail). Since both of these sensors have the exact same plug and now, since the added pigtail is present --> both connections are in just about the same place (behind the monster ram). He suggested that I check the wiring of the plug in my EGR. The wire plugged into the EGR was wrong. So, I swapped the connections of the two plugs . . . and voila!! All the problems went away. The truck is a raped ape now. I am making an average 21-22 mpg on the highway (at 77-80 mph) and about 17-19 in the city. I suppose it would be better if I took my foot out of it. Sometimes I enjoy that pedal monster a little too much. I am absolutely confident that this is your problem. A trip to O'Reilly's to borrow their scanner cancelled the P0299 and P0111. Now that I have added the supergauges, I can cancel any codes from the driver's seat.

Let me know if this makes you whole.

Cheers!!

George
" Since both of these sensors have the exact same plug and now, since the added pigtail is present --> both connections are in just about the same place (behind the monster ram). He suggested that I check the wiring of the plug in my EGR. The wire plugged into the EGR was wrong. So, I swapped the connections of the two plugs . . . and voila!! All the problems went away."

THANKS FOR SHARING THIS!!!
I'm glad I'm not the only person to have ever cross connected the sensor leads. I would have never thought to look at this if it were not for you sharing this!!
 
This post needs to be commented on every day or two for purely entertainment purposes hahaha
 
I'm thinking locking it would be more fun.

you may want to take a moment, have a poop, watch some tik tok and circle back to what options are available to you. it's a big decision that may have major repercussion's later down the road.

i hope you choose wisely.
 
Monster intake - Flows a ton of air until it gets to the head. no gain. no improvement. Yes no bolt anymore, but that bolt failing is rare. so rare in fact, its almost a myth.

I keep this on my desk to remind me about my experience with this "myth"
67.jpg
 
i imagine if you gathered all of the failures you might have close to a full set. much like the dragonballs, they will be hard to find.

Probably because thew vast majority of Cummins owners aren't active on the forums. Its happened enough times for there to be a market to prevent the issue. I know one thing - no way I will ever own another 6.7 outside of warranty without preventative measures in place. If your feeling lucky, have at it. Some folks have to learn the hard way
 
Probably because thew vast majority of Cummins owners aren't active on the forums. Its happened enough times for there to be a market to prevent the issue. I know one thing - no way I will ever own another 6.7 outside of warranty without preventative measures in place. If your feeling lucky, have at it. Some folks have to learn the hard way

i mean, can it happen, sure. has it happen? Sure. But the only person talking about it if you do a basic search, is Banks. And forums quoting banks. and asking if banks is right?

I will also add this, i have owned 4 6.7's since 2009 and well not so much as a wiggle wiggle on any of them and that dang darn bolt banks has screamed about.
 
i mean, can it happen, sure. has it happen? Sure. But the only person talking about it if you do a basic search, is Banks. And forums quoting banks. and asking if banks is right?

I will also add this, i have owned 4 6.7's since 2009 and well not so much as a wiggle wiggle on any of them and that dang darn bolt banks has screamed about.

Actually with a basic search I found several failures being reported. r/Cummins in one thread there was 4 reports, and I was not one of them. So that is 5 in just one place.
Banks developed a complete well engineered solution to the problem, and they have a great marketing team with a healthy budget. You could just as easily go the GDP route, or use various other solutions to eliminate the OEM grid.
I used GDP on my 08, but the complete turn key solution through banks is very attractive.

Good for you. I am on my 5th 6.7, and I wasn't so lucky. Peace of mind is worth the expense even at Banks prices. When mine let go I had a trailer full of bikes in Sturgis and it created a giant headache. The cost of the solution would have been significantly less than what I had to spend on towing, rental and accommodations due to me being unable to leave town on the date I was supposed to.
 
After reading this thread I'm wondering a couple things:
1. is it possible that the increased sound level of the turbo, interpreted as increased air flow, is really caused by a shift in the sound frequencies thereby negating the effectiveness of the cabin noise canceling system?
2. has any kind of commonality for the heater grid failure be established? For instance, perhaps trucks in northern climes require longer preheat times than truck in warmer areas and the longer preheat allows the components to overheat.

Just a couple random thoughts that came to mind while reading...

PS: I must say that I lived in fear of the dreaded CP4 failure for six years and 300,000+ miles. This heater grid bolt issue is one that is always at the edge of my mind, if I were to eliminate this potential problem, the cost would amortize out at less than $200.00 per year. Peace of mind is certainly worth that to me.
On the other hand, my observations and experience would indicate that modifying any vehicle in a way that is not within manufactures parameters ultimately leads to increased wear and tear and a shorter service life.
 
Back
Top