I was in the exact same position. Ordered OEM and ended up with Weathertech. The two piece design of the OEM I have in my JLUR and I hate how it likes to come apart at the connection of the two pieces in the back. with WT dont need to worry about that.I wanted the Mopar but ended up with the Weathertech. They are one piece in the back. The fit is great and the mat is not too stiff or heavy for me to reach the in-floor storage bins. I have Weathertech in my Jeep LJ and my 2007 Ram. I feel the mats for my 2020 are better quality than those were. I have heard the Husky are good but my previous experience with them in my Jeep was bad so I did not consider them.