gimmie11s
Well-Known Member
- Messages
- 2,677
- Reaction score
- 3,973
- Points
- 113
Not in reality. At the end of the day, the only thing that matters is reducing the overall energy requirements. Taller tires are still at a mechanical disadvantage due to the longer lever of the increased radius. That's why people need to regear to move them. If they were more efficient you'd accelerate faster and maintain speed *easier* with larger tires, which obviously you don't. Even ignoring minor factors like sidewall flex and increased wind resistance, if no other factors change the shorter tire will get better fuel economy. Now, if you go to a taller tire with much stiffer sidewalls and lower rolling resistance, THOSE variables may make up for the others and you end up with better fuel economy. Going from a 33" mud tire to a 35" road tire, for example. Cleatus lore may confuse that with getting better fuel economy due to the taller tire, but it's not what happened.
I'd agree --if-- there was a heavy mix of city driving.
However, once on the highway -- for an extended period of time, my theoretical example listed above would get superior mileage due to the reduced effective gear ratio.
I largely agree with what you are saying though.


