I've actually had both experiences with the factory LSD. My 2015 Ecodiesel with Mopar Anti-Spin differential sucked, it never seemed to lock up when i needed it in snow or ice, I remember one day i had the passenger side of the truck in some deeper snow with an ice base, and driver side on a little hard pack with a pavement base, and it just spun the passenger side tire until i really started revving it. I haven't had my 2500 in the snow yet, so i can't compare my 2500 in snow performance yet.
However I do have another example where i can say my 2019 6.7 LSD works very well compared to my 2015. My house is on a hill, the garage and driveway are on a flat spot in the middle of the hill, and half my yard is up the hill, half my yard is down the hill. So to get to my upper yard there's a steep little grass hill that's only about 1.5 car lengths wide and there's no run up to it, you have to make a sharp left as you start to climb up it. My 1500 with anti-spin always needed 4wd, even with my big 35" BFG K02's, the truck would flex a bit and the inside rear wheel would get light and just spin, the outer wheel would push a little bit, but ultimately i'd end up using 4wd if i didn't want to tear up the grass too bad. My new 2019, right up in the hill in 2wd, absolutely zero drama, even with the crappy Firestones, i was super impressed.
So it was basically a night and day difference between my 2015 with Mopar LSD and my New 2019 with Mopar LSD.