Unless the Duratrash tires are COMPLETELY different from 2017 to when you guys bought yours, which could be the case. I had all of them have multiple flat tires under 15K. I looked at a set on a Rebel the other day, and they at least still had what I call the Alligator skin between lugs. Most of my flats were rocks getting under those little flaps. But the belts were hard and fragile like glass, and if a side wall even looked at anything it was ripped open. And everyone else was getting non stop flats at the time. I was once parked next to a Hyundai RENTAL STREET CAR changing 2 flats( one repair) on a gravel road, talk about embarrassing, his cheap street tires were fine. The tires were so bad, even if they have made changes not sure I could take the risk. I do drive off road every single day to my house, which could be part of what's different for me. Subarus last a few years in our neighborhood before being completely worn out needing a ground up rebuild for instance.