At the end of the day, it doesn’t really matter how you hook up the trickle charger. If it’s hooked straight to the negative post, it’s still going to charge the battery like it normally would, and stop charging when it doesn’t need to, and the IBS will pick up on the SOC after an ignition cycle.
Where it really matters is when using wiTECH to do extended diagnostics, and a charger needs to be hooked up to maintain SOC during a flash. Since the BCM is receiving the IBS info, and reporting the SOC on wiTECH, if the charger is hooked up to the negative post, the IBS won’t reflect the maintained SOC. If the reported voltage drops below a certain threshold, wiTECH won’t allow the flash to be performed.
Next time I get a chance, I can get some screenshots of the difference in how the voltage is reported by having the charger on the negative post, vs the IBS post.