Fair points. I guess all I was trying to say was that if your only issue was the CP4 then it would be dumb to switch trucks solely for that considering the other truck has the same pump, albeit less likely to glitter bomb still very possible. From the sound of it you're facing a bad build build, which sucks. I've got some minor nits from my truck, HVAC being the only "big" issue outside the CP4.
To be clear, I wasn't trying to be a fanboy. I was a day away from buying a SD before I came back around to buying the Cummins. I really like what Ford has to offer across their lineup and really like the SD, I think it's a great truck overall and really like the boxy look so I don't at all fault you for dumping yours if you decide to. The only vehicle I fanboy over is my dream car, a 66 continental sedan.
I'm keeping my fingers crossed FCA does the right thing with this pump. They seem to have taken care of us in relation to the HVAC according to the TSB so I'm hopeful here. For me, and my long term truck plans I think it will be cheaper to keep the truck no matter the decision FCA chooses to make but I guarantee that if FCA doesn't take care of us I won't be buying a jeep or challenger from them if they choose not to and won't be taking my vehicles to their service department either if that is the case.