Glad I found this thread. Currently have a Gator tri-fold soft cover on the truck. Love it, but with dogs and a kid on the way I needed more useable room for the pups...so a camper shell was the natural progression.
I was torn between two choices for my Power Wagon & price isn't necessarily the major driving force. I looked at fiberglass covers and based upon feedback here...I was really only comfortable with SnugTop. But with no snugtop dealer within 5 hours and a $3200+ pricetag...I wasn't willing to make a drive/install/potential hotel just for it.
It really came down to two tops at that point. First being the soft topper which appears to be really popular. I like the convertible like features, ease of installation, and price point. But I really dislike its security and ability to host my two dogs on road trips/camping.
Ultimately, I chose an RSI Smartcap Evo. Should be here in a week or so and I can't wait. I really liked the static/dynamic load ratings, pop up everything, & ability to use my cargo camera still. Dislike the fact that you can't unlock the cap from the inside...but I sleep primarily in my RTT/trailer combo.
Love reading about your caps and experiences though!