I've heard nothing but good things so I don't doubt it. The challenge the wife and I had with GD is that the cost is higher and it's not the exact layout we want. I wouldn't mind sacrificing either or but not both. If we were going to get a 5er I may feel different, but after weighing the truck last night I'm at 5060 front, 3300 rear axle weights. I figure I add another 180 per kid, maybe 110 for the wife, a lab and a yapper and I'm about 580lbs, prob have some odds and ends so let's round up to 700 just for sake of argument. Assuming since I've got a crew short bed that weight would be pretty evenly split I'm looking at a rear axle weight of 3650 with an axle rating of 6k, only leaves 2350. Now, that is a pretty decent amount but a 12k trailer at 20% pin would put me about 50lbs over. To be fair I'm stacking safety margins a bit there, and I'm sure that the rear axle is likely actually capable of much more than 6k extended use, so I'm still a little up in the air.
We are going on a trip mid July, so I need to either pull the trigger on renting, or buying, ASAP. Honestly, at this point it's getting down to pretty minor differences and all the reviews I'm reading seem to be mostly nitpicky stuff. I wish it wasn't the case, but seems trailers don't have the same build quality or protections as other stuff.